Skip to content
The Banoffee Pie Incident

The Banoffee Pie Incident

What goes ‘Whoa, bloody hell, plop’? I can tell you, it’s my wife, Debbie, carrying a freshly homemade Banoffee Pie from the kitchen to the dining room and managing to throw it, face down, on the carpet! Yes, a beautifully made, beautiful looking and very much coveted gorgeous tasting (well, it would have been), Banoffee Pie. Now reduced to no more than a squashed pulp of banana, cream and chocolate sludge spread about the carpet and part of the oak cupboard.

Carnage

Why oh why do these things always land face down? It was in a foil dish, why could it not have landed on its base, at least we would have been able to salvage some of it. I’m not sure who was more distraught, but I know who was laughing their socks off. I was bemused as to how or why she would throw such a work of art onto the carpet. It’s like one of those road traffic incidents that happen outside your house on a quiet Sunday afternoon. All is going incredibly well and then carnage, complete and utter carnage.

Catastrophe

Our youngest daughter was visiting at the time and was also waiting in anticipation of the said dessert when catastrophe struck. As she is of the younger generation a phone immediately appeared in her hand almost before the pie had hit the ground. Within seconds, the proof was recorded for eternity through the photographs she took and messages of a ‘terrible occurrence’ happening were soon passed among family and friends. Some of the replies, well, they would have turned the cream on the pie sour!

Only Banoffee Pie

Another question I have is how come this sort of thing never happens with a Rhubarb Crumble or an Apple Pie? It only happens with a delicacy that’s full of cream chocolate and bananas that everyone loves. The day ended on a subdued note with lots of expletives, none of which were from me I might add. As for the wreckage of the (I can almost taste it) Banoffee Pie, it was cleaned from the carpet and like an ‘insurance inspection’ into the damage was considered well and truly written off. We have had a laugh about it though, but I hope it never happens again.

Go On Make One

If you ever fancy the idea of making a Banoffee Pie, we have a recipe here:
Banoffee Pie Recipe. If you do decide to make it, I hope you have much better luck than we had and it reaches your table. I can also recommend Jamie Oliver Banoffe Pie recipe, his seems to have a lot more chocolate in it.


49 thoughts on “The Banoffee Pie Incident”

  1. Oh, my goodness! I would have been crying at such a splodgy accident.
    Now though, I want a slice of Banoffee pie, and I don’t normally have a sweet tooth!

    1. Trev, the above comment was from me SueW.
      It’s a puzzle that I can click Like as me, but it doesn’t recognise me when I comment!
      I’m guessing the same thin happened yesterday too. I’ll go back to your post and check. 🙂

      1. Thank you, Sue. I’m sorry about the problems with the comments. WordPress can act very strange at times and I have no idea why. It’s a real puzzle. Thank you for persevering, it’s truly appreciated, Sue. 😊

  2. So who was the beast that laughed their socks off? I’ve never had a pie incident but there have been thefts by certain dear four-legged criminals and I once picked up a new bag of cat kibble only to have the bottom open dumping the lot on the floor. I had a lot of help sorting that out, of course. But oh, a particularly longed for pie…that is sad!

  3. Well, here is yet another UK-ism thingie I have never met. But at least this pie is a pie, and not some strange meat concoction. (If you recall from *my* blog, I have a trip to Scotland, and perhaps a move there as well in my future, and things UK are being learned… sort of.) However different our two countries may be (a tv program only has one m and no e…) things landing face down onto the floor is universal, doubly so if it is carpet. You may have hit the five-times range because it is a light colored (only one U) carpet. Something different from there to here though, if my significant other was laughing at this, the next thing to be wearing said pie wouldn’t be more carpet. 😀 (The mutual laughing would come later, much later.)

    1. Banofee Pie is excellent, if you can keep it from straying onto the floor. Well, I’m in Wales which is sort of like Scotland but much smaller and the mountains and hills here are much smaller. And you’re right about things landing face down, that is a universal law, something Isaac Newton would probably know about. Thank you. 🙂

  4. lord a fall upside down cake to match our world affairs. Glad you got a laugh but I’m afraid she might throw the next one smack dap in the face, Trev.. good luck! Banoffee pie is a new one for me.

I'd love to hear from you

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.